The evolution of employee benefits communication
In a world of constant distraction, the barrage of emails and ever increasing social media chatter, employers are finding it harder than ever to connect with employees. But one thing is clear: When it comes to benefits, historical means of communication no longer cut it.
Only 22% of HR professionals surveyed for a Society for Human Resource management study on communicating benefits said that they strongly agree with their organizations employee benefits communication efforts. But with such a massive amount of compensation locked up in benefits according to the Department of Labors most recent data, approximately 31% of compensation for employees in the private sector is spent on benefits benefit decision-makers have a responsibility to ensure employers investment is delivering value. And yet it remains incredibly difficult, particularly with an annual open enrollment cycle, to measure the effectiveness of benefit communications delivered through traditional means such as paper, or even email.
But innovative organizations are pioneering new ways of communicating complex health care, benefits and other workplace information to employees and, more importantly, measuring results.
For the past two years, the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association, the professional association for speech-language pathologists, audiologists and speech and hearing scientists, based in Rockville, Md., has been using Airbo, an engagement and communication platform that works much like Pinterest, only for employee communications. Twenty-two percent of ASHAs workforce is age 34 or under, and the organizations human resources director, Janet McNichol, was looking for ways to better engage and educate this demographic.
Benefit managers and other users create tiles on the platform, which are then posted to a virtual bulletin board. An email gets sent to employees, alerting them a new tiles been posted. Employees then visit the board on whatever device theyre using, while employers can see metrics in real-time about how their employees are engaging in the messaging.
As employees work their way through the content, theyre guided to answer a question at the end, which is designed to gauge their understanding of the information. McNichol says new content averages about 100 completions, meaning 100 of ASHAs 275 employees have read the information and answered the question. The same cant be said for intranet messages and emails, she says.
And yet despite the rapid adoption of smartphones and tablets, many employers are still communicating through these mostly traditional means.
Ive seen large organizations where HR sends out a monthly email thats five pages long, says Keith Kitani, CEO of Guidespark, an employee engagement and communication company that primarily uses video to help employers communicate about benefits. How can any employee sort through all these [benefit] programs and figure out which ones to use and really connect with?
Indeed, when Jennifer Crick, director of human resources at Alta California Regional Center, a nonprofit organization that serves developmentally disabled people in California, recently surveyed her workforce to ask them how they preferred to receive information, just one-third of the organizations 418 employees said they prefer email only. Two-thirds said they prefer other methods, or a combination of multiple methods.
Emails go into a void, she says. You dont know if people are reading them or paying attention to them or taking action on them.
Crick recently finished piloting Airbo for an annual compliance form employees are required to complete. As a state-funded organization, all employees have to fill out a conflict of interest form each year by July 31. Crick used Starbucks gift cards as an incentive and assigned points to employees who acted on the tile by submitting the completed compliance form in advance of the deadline. She says she saw a much higher completion rate this year on the initial request to fill out the forms. A week before the deadline, about 92% of employees had submitted their completed forms whereas in years past, Crick estimates the completion rate was maybe 65%. She is now planning on using Airbo for open enrollment communications.
I was able to share that [data] with our chief operating officer and say Look, these tiles are being interacted with, these are driving action by our staff and [employees] are taking responsibility in moving forward with what we are asking them to do, she says.
There is no one-size-fits-all way to engage with all employees, but employee expectations of benefits communications are being shaped by the seismic shift in peoples lives as consumers, says Kaulen Taylor, a partner with Aon Hewitt.
The way were used to being communicated with as individuals in the consumer marketplace is vastly different than the way were engaged and communicated with in the employee workplace, she notes. That disconnect between my life outside work and the way Im engaged with [at work] just widens and I think employers are challenged to keep up with that.
Word of caution
But benefit decision-makers should be cautious when implementing new digital tools and platforms, says Vlad Gyster, CEO and founder of Airbo, who believes the consumerization of employee communication should benefit HR managers just as much as employees.
Its important to keep in mind the everyday environment [benefit] managers are operating in. There are so many different competing priorities, and there are less HR people than ever to support each employee, he says. The risk is [these tools] could be perceived as making more work for [them] when there is not much capacity left.
As benefit managers evaluate new communication technologies, they should almost be a little bit selfish about it because that is the best thing for employees, he continues. Find ways to implement these technologies that reduce your workload as well. It cant just be about boosting employee engagement because thats not sustainable. It has to be about enabling HR to do more with dwindling resources to make their employees more and more successful and happy and more productive at work.
Some employers point to differences in generational habits being one of the bigger communication hurdles to jump when crafting benefits messaging and considering delivery strategies.
Traditional print communications are what baby boomers have grown up with, and they may be used to getting information that way, Kitani says. And yet, based on his experience, companies with employees whose average age is late 40s have reported seeing higher, if not the highest, engagement rates in video.
Its interesting we all jump to the conclusion that this is only for the young generation, but the 6 billion views on YouTube a month are not just by young people, theyre by everyone, he says. The change in communications is taking hold at different age groups.
ASHAs McNichol admits she believed Airbo would appeal primarily to the millennials at the organization but one of the tools biggest fans is set to become Medicare-eligible this year. Sometimes I think we expect our younger staff to prefer those tools and thats not necessarily the case, she says. We do try to put the information out there lots of different ways so we can meet people where they are.
In addition, shes taken a new approach to the more traditional one-and-done communication strategy. People think something has been communicated they check it off their list when its been posted or shared in some way, she says. The way we define it here is, it hasnt been communicated until somehow the person on the receiving end has acknowledged theyve received it. We just keep putting it out there again and again in all these different ways until people are acknowledging that theyve received it. When we get signals that people have received the information and made a choice about it, then I can check it off the list.
Understanding the needs of the employee audience their behaviors, attitudes, and demographics and analyzing and segmenting that audience appropriately and being able to say these are the people we need to engage in these programs or activities will be important to creating new communication strategies, says Taylor.
It goes back to the less of the one-size-fits-all in communication and more targeted, precise one-to-one level of interaction that weve come to expect in other aspects of our lives, she continues. If I log on to something online, [it] knows Ive been here, knows what Ive bought, knows way more information about me than I could ever imagine and Im being set up and directed to the things that matter most to me based on the data points coming together.
Replicating that kind of consumer experience in the workplace will help employers in their goal of getting people get to the things that matter most to them, and cut out the noise of the other things that dont.
And as employers start to move toward more digital formats, measuring engagement levels will become easier. We think thats going to be a critical step for companies to think about when they try these new forms, says Kitani.
The big takeaway is that the shape of communication has shifted and now is the time to make that shift in the benefits/HR communications space, Taylor adds.
Once size wont fit all from a channel or message, she reiterates. Take baby steps to build out the ecosystem to be more dynamic and targeted. Itll take a lot of change, but now is the time. I think weve been sitting back as HR and benefits communicators. Theres no more waiting were about to be completely left behind.
With files from Andrea Davis.