Benefits Think

Enhancing employee benefits: The case for evolving HSA contribution strategies

Man looking at medication with pharmacist at pharmacy
Adobe Stock

Imagine staring at your monthly budget, only to be confronted by the inevitable rise in healthcare costs. The ongoing dilemma of choosing between everyday gas and groceries and safeguarding your well-being through your health insurance is a narrative that resonates with many. 

This is where health savings accounts (HSAs) enter the picture, designed as a financial cushion against medical expenses, but often found wanting just a little bit more in their support due to the contribution strategies made by well-intentioned employers.

Understanding traditional HSA contribution models

The conventional model of employer contributions to HSAs usually involves 'seed' contributions, a one-time or annual lump sum usually delivered at the beginning of the year. However, as noble as this seed strategy appears, it possesses inherent limitations. Employees, bound by budgetary constraints and personal financial goals, might not be able to maximize their HSA contributions. The one-time contribution method does not empower employees to see the opportunity they have in also contributing to their HSA, which is crucial in fostering consistent and substantial saving habits.

Read more:  Employees are winning the battle against RTO

The case for match or auto contributions

This brings us to the alternative: a match or auto contribution model. The essence of a match contribution is quite straightforward — with every dollar an employee contributes, the employer matches a percentage or a dollar-for-dollar method, effectively doubling the savings. Data supports this concept — HealthEquity recently compared two similarly sized organizations within their book of business in the hospitality industry — one implemented an employer match, and one did not. Both organizations target contributions of $500 for single employees and $1,000 to employees with a family. The company with a match required employee contributions before funds were contributed, while the seed-only option dispersed funds regardless of employee engagement.

The analysis uncovered several advantages to the match approach: Nearly 90% of employees at the organization used a match to their HSA, compared to just 40% of employees at the seed-only organization. At the same time, total HSA balances were, on average, 24% higher at the organization using a match. But that is not the only interesting finding. The organization using a match contributed roughly 20% less than the organization using the seed-only option. In addition, employee contributions at the organization using the match were 66% higher among single employees and 99% higher among employees with a family. What amazing results and behavior change!

Read more:  HSAs should be promoted as way to supplement retirement savings

Beyond the data view of the match method, auto contributions take it a step further, by automating regular contributions without requiring individual employee action. This consistent contribution strategy streamlines the savings process and habituates healthy financial behavior. This method takes either the premium savings of opting into the HDHP/HSA plan and contributing that automatically to the HSA, or setting a contribution amount at the start of the enrollment to the qualified medical plan.

Advantages of matching contributions

There's general evidence that Dr. Robert Cialdini's Principle of Reciprocity might extend to matching and contributed funds based on these initial findings. The ease of management propels employees under the matching and auto contribution model to feel more invested in their HSA — for every saving effort, there's a direct and consistent reward. The ease and benefits of these strategies, coupled with its consistent and undaunted pursuit of savings, crafts an environment ideal for fostering financial wellness. Employees are not just participants; they become active contributors to their long-term financial health, with the reassurance of a structured and dependable model. These evolved contribution strategies align the interests of both employer and employee in a tangible and motivating way. The ripple effect extends beyond healthcare, as the augmented savings can also supplement retirement funds, a thoughtful preparation for the future that resonates with employees and their families.

Read more:  Bank of America found that women's HSA balances are 15% lower than men's

Conclusion

In a world where the pull between financial stability and unforeseen healthcare expenditures is a recurrent theme, HSA contribution strategies stand as the bridge that can either bolster or diminish employee engagement. The shift from seed contributions to the more dynamic and rewarding match or auto contribution strategies is not just a financial acumen; it's a proactive step towards cultivating a healthier and more vested workforce.

I strongly encourage companies to look at their strategy and reconsider the pulse of their HSA contribution methods. Modernizing a contribution approach creates the opportunity not just for employee benefit, but for the holistic growth of the company. Employer actions in this important employee facet of their lives are not mere corporate fine-tuning; they ring out as a testament to the intentional stewardship of the employee's financial landscape. 

We know the success of any business is inextricably linked to the welfare and engagement of its workforce. From seed to match or auto contribution, the evolution of HSA contribution strategies paves a way for profound change in management, employee satisfaction of benefits , and ultimately, in societal well-being. It's the perfect time for employers to take the match or auto contribution dash and set a pace that resonates with the growing needs of their employees — fostering a culture of true partnership and mutual growth to create remarkable outcomes.

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
Employee benefits Financial wellness Healthcare
MORE FROM EMPLOYEE BENEFIT NEWS