Scams against retirees soared to 'crisis' levels in 2022

Scams robbed Americans of a record $8.8 billion in 2022.

Ron Strobel can still remember the panic in his client's voice. Six years ago, an elderly investor called Strobel's brokerage to say he'd just been scammed.

"He was distraught," recalled Strobel, a financial planner who today runs the firm Retire Sensibly in Meridian, Idaho. "It's bad enough to have your identity stolen, but I can't imagine watching it happen before your eyes and feeling helpless to stop it."

As the client, a Seattle retiree in his 70s, explained to Strobel over the phone, someone who claimed to work for Microsoft had just called him. The caller told him there was a virus on his computer and in order to remove it, they needed to remotely log into the machine. For some reason, "Microsoft" also asked the retiree to sign in to all his financial accounts.

"He eventually started to notice that something was wrong and told them to stop, but they kept stealing files from his computer as he watched the cursor bounce all over his desktop," Strobel said. "The only thing he could think of was to unplug his router, which turned the internet off."

Strobel and his co-workers sprang into action, helping the client contact his banks, change his account numbers and passwords, and get his credit report frozen. Luckily, they made it in time and no money was stolen. But the ordeal wasn't over.

"The craziest part was that a few hours after this incident, we received the exact same scam call at our office, presumably from the same scammer," Strobel said. "It was very bizarre to go through the process of helping the client and then hours later be talking to the scammer himself."

Read more: 52% of retirees expect to pick up a part-time job to make ends meet

Unfortunately, Strobel's former client is far from alone. Scams are a rapidly growing problem in the United States, and they hit retirees hardest of all. According to new data from the Federal Trade Commission, Americans lost $8.8 billion to fraud in 2022 — 30% more than the losses in 2021. 

"It's a crisis," said Kathy Stokes, director of fraud prevention programs at the retiree advocacy group AARP. "And that $8.8 billion is only what we know. There's so much more fraud that's just not getting reported."

By far, the most lucrative targets are retirees. While the median loss for all age groups last year was $650, for victims aged 80 and older it was $1,674. Stokes said this is not because seniors are more gullible or senile than younger Americans — a commonly exaggerated stereotype — but because they generally have more savings.

"The reality is older people — not always, but ostensibly — have more wealth than younger people," Stokes said. "So when you're a younger person, a tech support scam … might cost you $200 — which is hard when you're in your 20s, but it's recoverable. It's not recoverable when you're 80 and you've lost your money."

Read more: From student loans to retirement, financial wellness benefits need to help four generations of employees

In particular, last year saw a huge jump in business-related frauds. Victims reported losing $3.8 billion to investment scams, more than twice the losses for that category in 2021. The second-biggest losses were to imposter scams, which claimed $2.6 billion — but even within that category, the fastest-growing subset was business imposters. These fraudsters, who pretend to be affiliated with famous corporations, took in $660 million in 2022, up from just $196 million in 2020.

"Investment scams are on a troubling upswing," the FTC said in a statement. "Doubling growth in just one year might sound like good news for business, but not if the business is investment scams."

How to help
But retirees are not helpless against these crimes, and neither are their financial advisers. There are a number of things wealth managers can do to stop their clients from being swindled or to help them recover their money afterward. 

For one thing, advisers can ask for a "trusted contact" — someone who can answer questions if the client can't be reached. The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority strongly encourages this practice, as does AARP.

"If the adviser can't reach the client, or the adviser is concerned that money is leaving the client's account and he's having a hard time getting the client to explain why, that trusted contact can be called and maybe try to intervene in the whole thing," Stokes said.

Read more: Bank of America reveals top retirement concerns amid inflation

Second, advisers can educate investors on how to spot and avoid scams. AARP offers Watchdog Alerts — emails and text messages describing the latest cons, so clients can catch them early. And for older customers who may be more vulnerable to cybercriminals, the price-comparing company AllConnect has published a free guide on how to use the internet safely.

Most of all, Stokes said, scam victims need to know that they should call the police. This may not accomplish anything right away, but if, years later, an opportunity comes up for restitution, it's vital to have a police report as a record of what happened. And in any case, Stokes said, scams should be treated as the crimes that they are.

"Education is critically important, but we cannot educate our way out of the crisis that we're in," Stokes said. "We have to have a meaningful law enforcement response."

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
Retirement Crime and misconduct Practice and client management
MORE FROM EMPLOYEE BENEFIT NEWS