Benefits Think

Strategic tips on making open enrollment work

Leader speaking to group of employees
Adobe Stock

Open-enrollment season is marked by both anticipation and anxiety. The annual process of selecting benefits can feel overwhelming, especially as the landscape of work and well-being continues to evolve. 

As someone who has worked closely with organizations to re-engage teams and rebuild trust, I know that the right approach to benefits communication can transform open enrollment from a stressful obligation into an empowering opportunity. For brokers and advisers, this is a pivotal moment to help employer clients move beyond the basics and create a benefits experience that truly connects with their people.

The stakes are higher than ever, with Gallup reporting that employee engagement has declined worldwide, resulting in a staggering $438 billion productivity loss. Benefits are no longer just a checkbox — they are an important differentiator for engagement, retention and organizational culture. Employees want benefits that reflect their unique needs, life stages and aspirations. They want to feel seen, heard and valued. 

Yet, too often, open enrollment is treated as a transactional event: a flurry of emails, a stack of plan documents and hope that employees will make good choices. This approach misses the mark. Research shows that when employees are confused or disengaged during open enrollment, they are more likely to make suboptimal choices or worse, disengage from the process altogether. That's a missed opportunity for both employers and their people.

Read more:  A new employer care kit to address suicide prevention

Benefits are not one-size-fits-all. The most effective programs are those that recognize the diversity of employee needs and empower people to choose what's right for them. Employers should break down benefits into meaningful categories such as family well-being, financial wellness, career development and mental health. By framing options in terms that resonate with employees' real lives, organizations can help people see the value in their choices. 

Personalization goes beyond plan design. It's about understanding the unique circumstances of each employee and providing guidance that meets them where they are. For example, a new parent may prioritize family health coverage, while a recent graduate might be more interested in student loan assistance or professional development. Advisers can help clients map out these categories and develop communication materials that speak directly to different employee segments.

Managers are the bridge between HR and the front lines, often being the first point of contact when employees have questions or concerns about their benefits. Yet, many managers feel ill-equipped to have these conversations. Equipping managers with the details and insights they need to champion benefits programs, answer questions and address concerns is essential. When managers become advocates, they personalize the experience for their teams, helping employees feel seen and supported. 

Advisers can offer training workshops or toolkits to help managers step confidently into this role. Hosting manager-specific briefings or creating quick-reference guides empowers managers to answer common questions and direct employees to additional resources. When managers are engaged and informed, they can help demystify the process and build trust that spreads across the organization.

Read more:  HomeVest is helping employees save for their first home

Providing multiple communication channels

No two employees access information the same way. A centralized benefits hub is essential, but it's just the start. Employers should use a mix of communication channels including short-form videos, interactive presentations, live Q&A sessions and even text message reminders to make benefits information accessible and engaging. The more touchpoints, the greater the chance employees will find the answers they need on their own terms. 

It's also important to consider accessibility and inclusivity. Are materials available in multiple languages? Are they easy to understand for employees at all literacy levels? The goal is to remove barriers and make it as easy as possible for employees to engage with their benefits.

Technology is a game-changer for benefits. From AI-driven suggestion engines to data analytics, employers can now tailor recommendations to individual preferences and life stages. Advisers can help clients explore platforms that go beyond static plan documents, offering dynamic, personalized guidance that empowers employees to make choices with confidence. 

For example, some platforms use data from previous elections, life events and even health risk assessments to suggest the most relevant benefits for each employee. Others offer interactive decision support tools that walk employees through their options step by step. By leveraging technology, employers can provide a more personalized and supportive experience without overwhelming their HR teams.

Read more:  Most working mothers lack reliable lactation support at work, survey shows

This year, personalization and flexibility are top of mind. Employees expect benefits that reflect their evolving needs, whether that's mental health support, financial planning tools or career development resources. Advisers should encourage clients to listen actively to employee feedback and adapt offerings accordingly. 

The most successful organizations are those that treat open enrollment not as a checkbox, but as a chance to strengthen connection, trust and belonging. Mental health, in particular, remains a critical focus — especially with 32% of employees feeling frequently stressed at work. Employees are looking for resources that go beyond traditional employee assistance programs such as access to virtual therapy, mindfulness apps and peer-support networks. 

Financial wellness is also rising in importance, as nearly half of employees point to the rising cost of living as a significant source of stress. This is driving demand for tools and education to help manage debt, save for the future and navigate economic uncertainty.

Winning back employee engagement (and keeping it) requires ongoing, personalized connection. By listening, adapting and recognizing unique contributions, organizations can build a culture where benefits are more than just paperwork but a powerful tool for engagement and retention. 

As brokers and advisers, you have the expertise to guide clients through this process. By championing personalization, manager advocacy, diverse communication and technology, you can help employers turn open enrollment into a moment of real impact; one that strengthens relationships, builds trust and sets the stage for a more engaged, resilient workforce.

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
Employee benefits Employee retention Health and wellness Financial wellness
MORE FROM EMPLOYEE BENEFIT NEWS