6 tips for creating a competitive compensation model

Women shaking hands, man sitting next to woman smiling, job interview
Adobe Stock
  • Key insight: Learn why total rewards, not just base pay, determine hiring success.
  • What's at stake: Misaligned pay bands can drive turnover and inflate recruiting costs.
  • Forward look: Prepare for increased pay transparency and regular equity auditing across industries.
    Source: Bullets generated by AI with editorial review

Processing Content

If you're running a business and struggling to attract or hold onto good people, your compensation model might be the problem. A weak pay structure can cost you candidates and the employees you already have. Here, we explore some tips for creating a competitive compensation model.

Start with market data

You can't build a competitive pay structure without knowing where the market sits. Pull salary benchmarking data from sources like the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, industry associations, or compensation platforms like Payscale.

Look at your specific industry, geography, and company size. What a mid-sized tech firm in Austin pays for a marketing manager isn't what a regional logistics company in Ohio should pay for the same role. Get specific, and update your data at least once a year.

Be fair

When employees doing the same work at the same level get paid differently based on factors that have nothing to do with performance, that's a problem. Take a systematic approach to pay equity by auditing your compensation data across gender, race, tenure, and job function on a regular basis.

Read more:  Most workers expect AI layoffs as workplace stress and distrust grow

Know that compensation isn't just salary

Base salary gets most of the attention, but it's only one piece of the puzzle. The reality is that compensation comes in many forms, including bonuses, equity, paid time off, health benefits, retirement contributions, flexible work arrangements and professional development funding.

Employees want and consider all of it. In fact, a candidate could very well turn down a higher base salary somewhere else to work for you because your total package is stronger.

Build pay bands with room to grow

Pay bands give you structure without locking you into rigid numbers. Each role or job family should have a defined minimum, midpoint and maximum. The range needs to be wide enough to reward tenure and performance but tight enough to stay financially sustainable. Bands also help you avoid compression, which is when newer employees end up earning close to or more than experienced ones. That's one of the fastest ways to lose your best people.

Read more:  Companies that invest in women outperform competition

Bring in outside expertise to remove bias

Internal teams often have blind spots when it comes to compensation. People get attached to how things have always been done, or they underpay certain roles because those positions feel less visible. If your structure hasn't been audited in a few years, or if you're building one from scratch, you might consider an interim HR leader to bring an objective, outside perspective. They can assess your current structure, flag equity issues and help you build something defensible before you scale.

Keep it transparent with your team

You don't have to publish every salary, but employees should understand how you make pay decisions. That means being clear about what factors influence compensation, how raises work and what someone needs to do to move up in their band. Transparency reduces resentment and rumors. When people understand the system, they're more likely to trust it, even when they don't get exactly what they want.

Read more:  Employers are investing in virtual care to close healthcare gaps

Your structure is only as good as your commitment to it

Creating a competitive compensation model takes ongoing attention, honest assessment and the willingness to adjust when the data says you're off. If you treat compensation as a living part of your people strategy, you can keep better talent and spend less on recruiting. Start with the fundamentals, get outside help when you need it and don't let your pay structure fall behind.


For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
MORE FROM EMPLOYEE BENEFIT NEWS
Load More