How to hire a 401(k) investment adviser
Employer plan sponsors often ask me which investment adviser credentials are most important to look for when hiring a 401(k) investment adviser. As a 401(k) investment adviser myself, I have observed a number of plan sponsors hiring the wrong advisers because they aren’t looking at the right investment adviser credentials and are using an incorrect set of criteria to judge who is best.
Following are some universal, common sense criteria that plan sponsors can apply when hiring a 401(k) investment adviser along with important investment adviser credentials to evaluate. The information is divided into what I would consider the three major categories plan sponsors should evaluate: fiduciary responsibility, firm and background.
Hire an A.I.F. A big part of your job is to ensure that your 401(k) plan is always in fiduciary compliance. There are plenty of 401(k) investment advisers to choose from who are fiduciary compliance specialists. Look for the Accredited Investment Fiduciary (A.I.F.) designation as an indicator of who is capable and qualified in this area.
Fiduciary liability insurance. The 401(k) investment adviser you are thinking of hiring should be able to produce a certificate of insurance showing fiduciary liability coverage. Don’t accept assurance from the lead sales professional that coverage exists. Many of my competitors “self-insure” when it comes to fiduciary liability insurance (which means they don’t have any).
Written fiduciary promise. Many investment advisers are not excited about putting their fiduciary responsibilities to your plan in writing. Print off an unsigned version of a fiduciary pledge and ask them to sign it. If an adviser is unwilling to put these sorts of common sense promises in writing, drop them from your search.
See also: 10 best practices in 401(k) plan design
Work for an investment advisory firm. This may seem logical, however, there are a lot of plan sponsors that hire accounting firms or banks to provide 401(k) investment advisory services to their plans. Hire a professional who works for a firm whose core business is providing investment advice. There is a major difference in the quality of advice you will receive. Work for an RIA. I admit that I am biased since my firm is a Registered Investment Advisory (RIA) firm. RIAs are different from brokers. A RIA is required to put a client's best interests first and act as a fiduciary with regard to any recommendations shared. Brokers work for their brokerage firms, not their clients. In addition, the DoL’s final fiduciary regulations provide loopholes for brokers to escape their fiduciary responsibility. Simplify the issue so you don’t have to worry about loopholes. Hire a RIA.
See also: How employers can optimize their 401(k) RFP approach
No conflicts of interest. Many employers use investment advisers who are required to recommend proprietary products or who aren’t able to work with the entire universe of investment options (there are more than 30,000 investment options!). Investment advisers who work for brokerage firms or mutual fund companies fall into these categories. They are conflicted. Hire an adviser who has no conflicts of interest and will make the best recommendations for your plan and participants.
Are objective. Don’t hire an investment adviser that is also an asset manager or recordkeeper. For example, many employers use mutual fund companies as their investment adviser as well as asset manager and/or recordkeeper. No surprise, these investment advisers tend to overuse the investment funds their mutual fund family offers. These types of advisers have a conflict of interest which compromises their objectivity. As a result, following their recommendations may be a breach of your fiduciary duty.
Hire the best consultant. Check each prospective investment adviser’s background. You should find academic degrees in economics, finance and/or investments. Although English and music majors are smart too, they really don’t have the right academic credentials for this business. Move on to continuing education in the form of professional certifications. There are many professional certifications that are relevant and nearly all have some sort of continuing education requirement. Finally, check and see if the adviser has a deep history of working with 401(k) plans your size. Ten years is not enough. A strong 401(k) plan adviser needs to have experienced a number of significant up and down markets — not just one.
Check BrokerCheck. Studies have shown that investment advisers who have been sued in the past are likely to be sued again in the future. You shouldn’t work with problem advisers. Check the background of the advisers you are thinking of hiring using BrokerCheck. BrokerCheck is a free service provided by the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), a financial industry regulatory agency under the direction of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Any violation you find on the BrokerCheck website should cause you to drop an adviser from the list of advisers you are thinking of hiring.
Final thought: Avoid hiring the best sales team
This is the most common mistake I see plan sponsors make. But how do you avoid it? Some investment advisers are really good sales professionals. Try to identify if the sales professional is actually going to be working on your business if you hire them. Most investment advisers that are sales professionals first and consultants second typically do not enjoy servicing the business they sell. They leave the servicing function to others.
Since your ongoing relationship is going to be with the consultants servicing your business, make sure you spend the majority of your time during the sales process talking with them, not the sales professionals. Many times the service team (which you are about to become assigned to) is not of the same caliber as the sales team. The quality of the advice you will receive, reports you will review, and service you expect to experience, are often not the responsibility of the sales person trying to get your business.
Finally, the SEC has put together a nice list of questions that you may wish to consider asking a prospective investment adviser. Once you find a set of advisers that meet all these criteria, then it is just a matter of determining which one has the right cultural fit for your organization.