Employers, is your 401(k) plan as good as management says it is?

Over my 30-year career, I’ve worked with many 401(k) plans from Apple and IBM to John Deere and Mazda Motor Corporation. I have consulted with a number of great Fortune 500 companies on their retirement plans, as well as with hundreds of excellent small- and medium-sized companies. So I know what kind of qualities make up a great company retirement plan.

So how can you tell if your employer’s 401(k) plan is a good one? In my experience, the best 401(k) plans always possess the following attributes.

1. Availability of index investment options

Index mutual funds, such as the Vanguard 500 Index Fund, allow employees to invest in their 401(k) plans in a cost-efficient way. The best 401(k) plans offer a number of index fund options over the entire asset class spectrum. For example, index options should be available in at least the fixed income, U.S. equity and international equity asset classes.

Better 401(k) plans will have at least one fixed income index option, three U.S. equity index options and one international equity index option.

2. A cost-efficient target date series

If you are like most workers, you may find it easier to invest in your 401(k) plan using a target date fund. These funds are used by employees who don’t wish to actively manage their accounts and keep up with what is going on in the markets.

Target date investors contribute to only one fund for their entire careers. They invest in the fund named for the year closest to their expected retirement date.

See also: 7 signs of a successful 401(k)

The average target date fund expense ratio in 2015 was 53 basis points (or .53%). The target date funds your plan uses should have expense ratios that are close to that average to be considered cost-efficient.

Why is cost so important in a target date series? The highest-rated target series also tend to be the lowest cost. They achieve a lower average cost by including index investments within their underlying investments.

3. Availability of investment advice

Nearly all large 401(k) plans offer an investment advice option. Many investment advice options are free and are algorithm based.

Better 401(k) plans offer more than one option. For some options, like Financial Engines, employees may pay a fee to obtain a more personalized level of advice.

4. Feedback on how you are doing

On each of your quarterly statements, you should have information enabling you to gauge whether you are on track to accumulate a balance large enough to fund the retirement you desire.

This information could appear as an expected replacement ratio (for example, you are on track to replace 80% of your earnings) or it could be displayed as some sort of retirement readiness measure (you are in the red zone and not contributing enough).

5. Retirement calculators and projection tools

Planning is an important part of achieving. Your recordkeeper’s website, the same site you log into to view your account balance, should offer a robust selection of planning tools.

From retirement calculators to basic projection tools, you should be able to determine an expected 401(k) balance and what contribution rate is necessary to achieve it. You should also be able to add in a projected Social Security income stream and annuitize other balances (personal, spousal, your other 401(k) plans) to derive a projected monthly retirement income estimate.

Investors who achieve their retirement savings goals effectively use these types of planning tools.

6. You and your fellow employees understand the plan

The best 401(k) plans are well understood by employees. These plans tend to have straight-forward plan designs and a management team that can explain the plan easily.

For example, while visiting one of my clients, I heard employees say in an employee education session, “Look, you need to be in the 401(k) plan and you need to contribute at least 8% to receive the maximum company match. It’s that simple.”

See also: The top 25 401(k) plans

If you don’t understand your 401(k) plan, there’s a good chance you won’t get the most out of it.

7. Senior management talks about your plan

All of the best plans, without exception, receive significant support from the company’s leadership team. Company executives not only talk about the plan at official corporate gatherings, they feature it as a recruiting and retention tool in their everyday conversations.

How would you rate your 401(k) plan on these factors?

Register or login for access to this item and much more

All Employee Benefit News becomes archived within a week of it being published

Community members receive:
  • All recent and archived articles
  • Conference offers and updates
  • A full menu of enewsletter options
  • Web seminars, white papers, ebooks

Don't have an account? Register for Free Unlimited Access