A nationwide injunction filed Tuesday blocking the Department of Labor’s overtime rule — which was scheduled to go into effect Dec. 1 — leaves employers in limbo as to what to do next. But despite the uncertainty, experts say employers should go ahead with their compliance plans, should the rule go into effect.

Jeffrey Ruzal, an attorney with Epstein Becker Green, says that employers should continue to reclassify employees, even without the Dec. 1 deadline.

"The employer might want to pursue this opportunity to reclassify or change the role of the position so it fits in the role of the exemption," he says. "That way they're in a better position."

Employers should make sure they are enforcing the job duties test, which determines the exemption, as well.

"Although it is too early to speculate, the language used by the court suggests that it considers the 'duties test' the cornerstone of the overtime exemptions and the DOL's impermissible dilution of that test by also requiring an onerous salary minimum before reaching that test is inconsistent with the FLSA," says Regina Paul, partner at PhillipsNizer LLP. "I think that part of the issue here is when you make the salary test the most important part of the regulation, you never get to a duties test."

Ruzal says employers need to focus on compliance with the ruling up in the air.

"At least the employer went through the exercise of confirming that the duties are satisfied, and that way they'll know they are in compliance. That's just best practice."

A relief for employers

Overall the delay to the rule — which would make more than 4.2 million workers eligible for time-and-a-half wages — comes as a relief for many unprepared employers, particularly small business owners.

See also: IRS delays ACA reporting deadline

About 37% of small business owners said they aren’t “anywhere near ready” for the overtime rule changes, and 67% said they do not have formal compliance plans in place, according to online small business service directory Manta. And, nearly one third of more than 2,200 respondents said they weren’t actively taking steps to comply with the new rule.

[Image credit: Bloomberg]
[Image credit: Bloomberg]

The rule would bring the maximum salary cap to $47,892 a year for workers to be exempt from overtime pay requirements. For some employers, those costs will force them to completely rethink their business model.

“Employers can’t ignore the ancillary impact,” says Michael Schmidt, vice-chair of law firm Cozen O’Connor’s labor and employment department. “The more money employers have to pay for payroll, the less they’ll be hiring, the less they’ll be retaining.”

See also: Obama overtime pay expansion blocked by judge

The impact of upgrading some employees’ salaries, as per the regulations, could create negative feelings from senior management. The delta between lower-level and higher-level positions will be shortened, and senior employees might feel they deserve a raise as well, Schmidt says.

These issues, along with reclassifying employees, can be pushed away for now.

U.S. District Judge Amos Mazzant III granted the preliminary injunction on Tuesday and is still weighing a challenge to the requirement.

Some organizations, such as the Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of America, are happy with the ruling, which would have cost around $115 million each year.

See also: Lawsuits pile up against DOL’s overtime rule

“The rule, should it go into effect, will have a significant impact on many Big ‘I’ agencies and their small business and non-profit clients,” according to a statement from the association that represents a quarter of a million agents, brokers and employees. “As litigation continues, the Big ‘I’ — the only insurance trade association to sue the DOL — will continue to use all means necessary to fight this overly burdensome rule.”

Register or login for access to this item and much more

All Employee Benefit News becomes archived within a week of it being published

Community members receive:
  • All recent and archived articles
  • Conference offers and updates
  • A full menu of enewsletter options
  • Web seminars, white papers, ebooks

Don't have an account? Register for Free Unlimited Access