Benefits Think

Mental health at work: Why waiting until crisis is too late

Two female employees talking
Adobe Stock

Most doctors are trained to fix what's broken — but what if the focus shifted to preventing the break in the first place? 

This mindset is helping reshape workplace mental health strategies, where the true opportunity lies in helping employees thrive before they reach a crisis point. Proactive mental health care doesn't just benefit employees — it strengthens businesses, too, driving engagement, retention and performance while fostering a healthier, more resilient workforce.

Read more:  Flimp's new tool helps spouses compare their health plans

The hidden costs of delayed action

When mental health challenges go unaddressed, they can quietly erode workplace culture. Employees may struggle with focus, collaboration and motivation. Over time, this strain can escalate into absenteeism, burnout and turnover. 

Untreated mental health conditions can also significantly impact businesses, leading to substantial financial losses. For instance, absenteeism due to depression alone is estimated to cost U.S. businesses approximately $44 billion annually. Absences due to poor sleep cost U.S. businesses a staggering $44.6 billion in lost productivity. Furthermore, a study by Yale University found that mental illness costs the U.S. economy $282 billion each year, comparable to the economic impact of an average recession. 

These figures underscore the importance of investing in proactive mental health support to mitigate financial losses and enhance workforce well-being.​

"Most organizations today place little emphasis on mental health and even less emphasis on preventive action and care," noted Dr. David Ballard, a psychologist and former head of the American Psychological Association's (APA) Center for Organizational Excellence. "Even when workplaces provide mental health benefits and services, most of those benefits only handle situations when someone is already sick."

Too often, support only arrives when employees are already overwhelmed. Moreover, when organizations wait for visible signs of distress, they may miss opportunities to intervene early when support can be most effective. Employees in crisis may require extended leave, emergency interventions, or intensive support to recover, further straining resources.

Read more:  How leaders can prevent 2 of the worst open enrollment mistakes

Proactive support: Building a culture of prevention

Effective mental health strategies emphasize prevention rather than reaction. By embedding mental well-being initiatives into company culture, organizations can identify concerns early and provide meaningful support before issues escalate.

As Bill Tompkins, VP of Total Rewards at Miller Knoll, emphasizes in The Mental Health Advantage, "Mental health is part of a thriving well-being strategy, not something separate. It's not just about fixing problems when they arise, but creating an environment where employees feel supported long before they experience a crisis."

Key steps to a proactive approach include:

Promoting psychological safety: Encourage open dialogue about mental health. When employees feel safe discussing their struggles, they are more likely to seek support before reaching a breaking point.

Training managers as first responders: Equipping managers with tools to recognize early warning signs can lead to timely intervention. Training in active listening, empathy and referral resources empowers leaders to guide employees toward appropriate support.

Offering accessible resources: Comprehensive employee assistance programs (EAPs) with culturally tailored services can make employees feel seen and supported. Providing easy access to counseling, mindfulness tools, or stress management resources encourages employees to address concerns early.

Integrating mental health into workplace norms: Flexible work arrangements, regular check-ins and promoting work-life balance create an environment where mental well-being is prioritized.

"For mental health strategy, I believe in being proactive," suggests Desiree Pascual, Co-Founder and Chief Strategist at Simply Human, in The Mental Health Advantage. "We need to focus on creating the kind of work environments that actively prevent burnout, reduce stress, and promote mental well-being before it becomes a crisis."

Read more:  This AI-powered platform wants to overhaul your performance review process

The business case for proactive mental health support

Investing in proactive mental health initiatives pays off. Companies that prioritize well-being report increased employee engagement, improved retention rates and stronger team performance. Furthermore, employees who feel supported are more likely to contribute innovative ideas and foster a collaborative work culture.

It's not just about helping people because it's the right thing to do; it's also good for business. Proactive strategies reduce the need for costly crisis interventions while fostering a culture of trust and support.

However, to break the cycle of reactive mental health care, businesses must shift their mindset. Playing catch-up with people's mental health needs means that the root causes often go unaddressed. By integrating mental health into day-to-day operations, organizations can create a culture that supports employees long before they reach a crisis point.

Waiting until employees are overwhelmed is too late. A proactive approach not only prevents crises but also empowers individuals to thrive, driving long-term success for both employees and organizations alike.

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
Mental Health Employee benefits Workplace culture
MORE FROM EMPLOYEE BENEFIT NEWS