Benefit managers share their 7 open enrollment best practices

Calendar against a blue background
Adobe Stock
  • Key Insight: Discover how open enrollment is evolving into a strategic employee engagement and total-rewards platform.
  • What's at Stake: Rising healthcare costs and regulatory change could erode employer competitiveness and employee financial security.
  • Forward Look: Prepare for OBBBA compliance and AI-driven personalization reshaping benefits communication strategies.
  • Source: Bullets generated by AI with editorial review

Open enrollment is no longer just a compliance exercise — it's a strategic opportunity to strengthen employee engagement, address generational needs and demonstrate the value of your organization's total rewards. 

With shifting demographics, new technologies, and growing financial pressures, benefit leaders must adapt their strategies to meet employees where they are, while navigating new challenges and budget constraints. Leaders will have to consider three key areas this season: Affordability, engagement and education, says Todd Katz, head of group benefits at MetLife.

"We are seeing a big focus on healthcare costs: There is no doubt that healthcare inflation has absolutely pressured employers budgets and for that matter, employees budgets too. So I think every employer is thinking about what can we do with our health plan to optimize benefits in the most cost efficient way? Second, we're seeing employers very focused on engaging their workforce. How can I use my benefit plan in a way that creates real value for my employees?" Katz says. "And then third, as most employers move into this open enrollment season, is how do I make sure my employees understand their benefits?"

Katz and other top benefit managers and advisers shared their top lessons and tips to guide a successful open enrollment this year:

1. Address generational needs head-on

Employees across generations want and need different things from their benefits. Tailor your messaging and plan design to resonate with Gen Z, millennials, Gen X and boomers, acknowledging their unique priorities around health, financial security and flexibility.

Read more: Preparing for open enrollment: Generational tipping point shaping adviser strategies

2. Avoid the most common mistakes

Two pitfalls consistently undermine open enrollment: Overwhelming employees with jargon-heavy communications and failing to provide decision-making support. Simplify your messaging and ensure tools and resources are accessible in plain language.

Read more: How leaders can prevent 2 of the worst open enrollment mistakes

3. Lean on proven strategies for success

According to MetLife, four key tactics can elevate outcomes: Personalizing benefits education, using multiple communication channels, highlighting holistic wellness and connecting benefits to long-term financial security. 

Read more: MetLife shares 4 key strategies for a successful 2025 open enrollment

4. Focus on communication as a year-round strategy

Don't treat open enrollment as a one-time event. Create an ongoing communication cadence that prepares employees well before enrollment begins, reinforcing messages throughout the year to build confidence and engagement.

Read more: Strategic tips on making open enrollment work

5. Take a structured approach

Five steps can set you up for success: Assess last year's results, refine your goals, segment your employee population, deploy multi-modal communication and measure outcomes to continuously improve.

Read more: 5 steps to bolster outcomes this open enrollment

6. Explore new technologies for support

AI-powered tools are reducing the stress of enrollment by helping employees better understand and select benefits. These tools can also provide valuable data and insights for HR leaders looking to refine their strategies.

Read more: How this new AI tool is taking the stress out of open enrollment

7. Navigate regulatory and economic complexity with clarity

Amid evolving compliance requirements and financial pressures, benefit managers should frame benefits as a stabilizing force. Clearly communicate how benefits protect employees during uncertain times, and ensure your strategy accounts for new regulations like OBBBA.

Read more: How benefit managers can navigate open enrollment amid OBBBA

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
Open enrollment 2025 Healthcare costs Employee benefits
MORE FROM EMPLOYEE BENEFIT NEWS